Paper Citation Verify

---
name: paper-citation-verify
description: "Use when checking manuscript citations: bibliography hygiene, DOI/PMID completeness, placeholders, BibTeX key mismatches."
---

# Citation Verifier

## Overview

Use this skill when citation integrity is the bottleneck. It is narrower and more operational than general writing skills: the goal is to catch unverifiable references, missing identifiers, duplicated BibTeX keys, placeholder citations, and mismatches between local citation artifacts before they become submission problems.

Use this skill together with `scientific-writing` or `submission-audit`, not instead of them.

## When To Use

Use this skill when:
- a manuscript is close to submission or resubmission
- the bibliography may contain placeholders, guessed entries, or stale metadata
- a `.bib` file needs a hygiene pass
- the draft mixes DOI, arXiv, PMID, or plain-text references inconsistently
- you need to verify that local citation artifacts are ready before manual or online source verification

Do not use this skill for:
- generic literature discovery from scratch
- full manuscript restructuring
- venue formatting that does not depend on citation integrity

## Local First Pass

Start with a local citation scan before any online verification.

The upstream helper script is **not bundled with this repo**（ACAT-GOVERNANCE：上游脚本未随本仓库集成，
原宿主安装路径已废弃，不可直接调用，2026-08-29 审计标记；2026-09-23 宿主中性化改写）。
Run the scan directly instead. Look for:
- `[CITATION NEEDED]` or similar placeholders
- `PLACEHOLDER_...` citation keys
- `TODO: verify` markers
- DOI, arXiv, and PMID tokens
- LaTeX `\cite{...}` keys
- duplicate BibTeX keys inside `.bib` files

Treat imported BibTeX and Google Scholar-style exports as draft metadata, not as verified truth.

## Verification Order

1. Scan the local draft and bibliography artifacts.
2. Remove or flag all placeholder citations.
3. Check BibTeX-key uniqueness and obvious identifier gaps.
4. Normalize metadata fields that are commonly wrong in copied BibTeX:
   - author list and spelling
   - year
   - venue or journal name
   - volume, issue, pages, or article number
   - DOI versus preprint identifier
5. For every citation that matters to a scientific claim, verify the paper exists in trusted sources.
6. If a claim depends on a specific result, confirm the cited paper actually supports that claim.
7. Only then finalize formatting for the venue.

## Trusted Verification Sources

Prefer this order when moving beyond local scans:
- publisher page or DOI resolver
- PubMed for biomedical papers
- arXiv for preprints
- Crossref or Semantic Scholar for metadata cross-checking
- Google Scholar only as a fallback discovery aid, not as the sole source of truth

## Common Failure Modes

- writing BibTeX from memory
- leaving placeholder citation keys in the draft
- assuming an arXiv preprint and published version are interchangeable
- citing a paper correctly but using it to support a claim it does not make
- letting duplicate BibTeX keys silently overwrite entries
- blindly trusting copied Scholar or BibTeX metadata for venue names, pages, years, or DOI fields

## Output Standard

When using this skill, report:
- placeholder or unverifiable items
- duplicate or suspicious BibTeX keys
- missing or inconsistent DOI/arXiv/PMID information
- suspicious metadata fields that need manual correction
- claims that still need source verification
- the minimum safe next step before submission