Spec Creation

---
name: spec-creation
description: Spec creation with pattern references, acceptance criteria, and demo scripts. Use when creating implementation specs, defining acceptance criteria, or breaking down user stories.
---

# Spec Creation Skill

## Purpose

Guide spec creation with clear acceptance criteria, pattern references for execution agents, and testable success validation commands.

## When This Skill Applies

Invoke this skill when:

- Creating implementation specs
- Breaking down user stories
- Defining acceptance criteria
- Adding pattern references for execution
- Creating demo scripts for validation
- Translating business requirements to technical specs

## Stop-the-Line Conditions

### FORBIDDEN Patterns

```markdown
# FORBIDDEN: Missing acceptance criteria

## Implementation

Just do the thing.

<!-- No testable outcomes defined -->

# FORBIDDEN: No pattern reference

## Technical Approach

Build it however you want.

<!-- Execution agents need pattern pointers -->

# FORBIDDEN: No success validation

## Done Criteria

Looks good to reviewer.

<!-- No command to verify completion -->
```

### CORRECT Patterns

````markdown
# CORRECT: Clear acceptance criteria

## Acceptance Criteria

- [ ] User can click button → modal appears
- [ ] Modal shows validation errors for empty fields
- [ ] Successful submission shows success toast

# CORRECT: Pattern reference for execution

## Pattern Reference

- **UI Pattern**: `docs/patterns/ui/modal-form.md`
- **API Pattern**: `docs/patterns/api/crud-endpoint.md`
- **RLS Pattern**: `docs/patterns/security/rls-user-data.md`

# CORRECT: Success validation command

## Success Validation

```bash
# Run these commands to verify implementation
yarn test:unit --grep "ModalForm"
curl -X POST http://localhost:3000/api/endpoint -d '{"test": true}'
```
````

`````

## Spec Template (MANDATORY)

Every spec must include:

````markdown
# SPEC-{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}: {Feature Name}

## Summary

{One paragraph describing the feature}

## User Story

As a [user type], I want [goal] so that [benefit].

## Acceptance Criteria

- [ ] {Testable criterion 1}
- [ ] {Testable criterion 2}
- [ ] {Testable criterion 3}

## Pattern References

- **UI**: `docs/patterns/ui/{pattern}.md`
- **API**: `docs/patterns/api/{pattern}.md`
- **Database**: `docs/patterns/database/{pattern}.md`
- **Security**: Follow RLS patterns in `docs/database/RLS_IMPLEMENTATION_GUIDE.md`

## Success Validation Command

```bash
# Run this to verify the feature works
{validation command}
`````

## Demo Script

1. Navigate to {page}
2. Click {button}
3. Observe {expected behavior}
4. Verify {success indicator}

## Logical Commits

1. `feat(scope): implement data model [{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}]`
2. `feat(scope): add API endpoint [{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}]`
3. `feat(scope): create UI component [{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}]`
4. `test(scope): add unit tests [{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}]`

````

## Acceptance Criteria Patterns

### User Action Criteria

```markdown
- [ ] User can {action} → {result}
- [ ] When user {triggers}, system {responds}
- [ ] User receives {feedback} after {action}
```

### Data Criteria

```markdown
- [ ] Data persists after {action}
- [ ] User can only see their own {data type}
- [ ] {field} validates {constraint}
```

### Error Criteria

```markdown
- [ ] Invalid input shows {error message}
- [ ] Network failure shows retry option
- [ ] Unauthorized access returns 401
```

## Pattern Discovery for Specs

Before writing any spec:

```bash
# Find existing patterns
ls docs/patterns/

# Search for similar implementations
grep -r "similar feature" app/ lib/

# Check existing specs for format
ls specs/
cat specs/SPEC-{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-XXX-example.md
```

## Spec Quality Checklist

Before submitting spec:

- [ ] All acceptance criteria are testable (can verify pass/fail)
- [ ] Pattern references point to existing patterns
- [ ] Success validation command is runnable
- [ ] Demo script is step-by-step reproducible
- [ ] Logical commits follow SAFe format
- [ ] Linear ticket referenced

## Output Locations

| Output Type  | Location                                              |
| ------------ | ----------------------------------------------------- |
| Impl specs   | `specs/SPEC-{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}-{description}.md`            |
| Requirements | `docs/agent-outputs/requirements/{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}-*.md`   |
| ADRs         | `docs/adr/ADR-{number}-{description}.md`              |

## Evidence for Linear

After spec approval:

```markdown
**BSA Spec Evidence**

**Spec**: specs/SPEC-{{TICKET_PREFIX}}-{number}-{description}.md
**Status**: Approved by [reviewer]

**Deliverables**:

- [x] Acceptance criteria defined
- [x] Pattern references added
- [x] Demo script created
- [x] Ready for implementation
```

## Authoritative References

- **Spec Template**: `docs/archive/specs/spec_template.md`
- **Pattern Library**: `docs/patterns/README.md`
- **Planning Guide**: `docs/team/PLANNING-AGENT-META-PROMPT.md`
- **SAFe Workflow**: `CONTRIBUTING.md`
````