003 Name Skill Bc827437

---
name: create-claw-skill
description: >
  This skill should be used when the user asks to "create an OpenClaw skill",
  "make a claw skill", "build a skill for OpenClaw", "write a SKILL.md for openclaw",
  "add a skill to openclaw", "generate openclaw skill frontmatter", "create a clawhub skill",
  or wants to author a new skill for the pi-coding-agent / OpenClaw ecosystem.
argument-hint: "[skill|command] [name] - or leave empty to interview"
---

# OpenClaw Skill & Command Generator

Generate well-structured OpenClaw skills or slash commands. Both are SKILL.md files with YAML frontmatter — they share the same structure but differ in how they're triggered and described. OpenClaw uses the AgentSkills spec (pi-coding-agent) with its own frontmatter fields, tool names, and path conventions distinct from Claude Code.

## Phase 0: Fetch Current Documentation

**Before generating**, retrieve the latest OpenClaw skill documentation:

```bash
clawdocs get "tools/skills" --no-header -q
```

Capture any frontmatter fields or options not already listed in `{baseDir}/references/frontmatter-options.md`. If `clawdocs` is unavailable, proceed with current references — they are sufficient. If new fields appear, use them and note the update.

## Phase 1: Understand Requirements

Parse `$ARGUMENTS` for type hint. Users are often unclear on OpenClaw-specific conventions. Interview to gather:

1. **Primary objective** — What should this skill do?
2. **Trigger scenarios** — When should it activate? What exact phrases would a user say?
3. **Inputs/outputs** — What does it receive and produce?
4. **Complexity** — Simple, standard, or complex workflow?
5. **Gating needs** — Does it require specific binaries, env vars, or config keys? (drives `metadata.openclaw.requires.*`)
6. **Execution needs** — Sub-agent delegation via `sessions_spawn`? Command dispatch (bypass model)?

Proceed to Phase 2 when at minimum Objective and Trigger Scenarios are established.

## Phase 2: Generate

Apply throughout generation: use imperative voice and terse phrasing because every token in a generated skill body costs budget on every invocation. Prefer instruction over example — state the rule with its reasoning so it generalizes to every input.

**Initialize directory first (when creating a new skill directory, not editing an existing file):**

```bash
python3 {baseDir}/scripts/init_claw_skill.py <name> --path <dir> [--resources scripts,references,assets]
```

Exit 0 = directory scaffolded, proceed to Step 1. Exit 1 = naming collision; ask user whether to overwrite or rename.

### Step 1 — Choose type

- **Skills:** Trigger-rich, third-person description ("This skill should be used when..."); auto-triggered by routing
- **Commands:** Concise, verb-first description, under 60 chars; user-invoked via `/` menu
- **Dispatch commands:** `command-dispatch: tool` with `command-tool` — bypasses model entirely, routes directly to a named tool (rare; for pure pass-through cases)

### Step 2 — Write frontmatter

Read `{baseDir}/references/frontmatter-options.md` for the full OpenClaw field catalog, description patterns, and the `metadata` single-line JSON constraint.

Key constraint: **`metadata` must be a single-line JSON object on one line.** Multi-line YAML mappings under `metadata` are not valid in OpenClaw.

**Intensional over extensional** — state the rule with its reasoning rather than listing examples that imply the rule. An intensional rule generalizes to every input the skill will encounter; an extensional list only covers the shapes shown.

### Step 3 — Write body

**Construction rules:**
- State objective explicitly in first sentence
- Use imperative voice ("Analyze", "Generate", "Identify") — no first-person ("I will", "I am")
- Context only when necessary for understanding
- XML tags only for complex structured data
- No "When to Use This Skill" section — body loads only after triggering; routing guidance there is never read by the routing decision
- Avoid headers deeper than H3 — deep nesting signals content that belongs in `references/`, not `SKILL.md`
- `{baseDir}` is the path variable for skill-relative file references (substituted before model sees the skill body)

Both skills and commands follow the same body pattern:

```markdown
# Name

Brief overview (1-2 sentences).

## Process
1. Step one (imperative voice)
2. Step two
3. Step three
```

**Dynamic Content:**

| Syntax | Purpose |
|--------|---------|
| `$ARGUMENTS` | All arguments as string |
| `$1`, `$2`, `$3` | Positional arguments |
| `{baseDir}` | Absolute path to skill directory (substituted at load time) |

Note: `@file` injection and bang-backtick command expansion are Claude Code features specific to Claude Code's skill loader implementation — the pi-coding-agent skill loader only supports `{baseDir}` path substitution and does not implement these extensions. Do not use them in generated OpenClaw skills.

### Step 4 — Script opportunity scan

Read `{baseDir}/references/script-patterns.md` and apply the five signal patterns to every workflow step in the skill being generated:

| Signal | Question | If yes → |
|--------|----------|----------|
| **Repeated Generation** | Does any step produce the same structure with different params across invocations? | Parameterized script in `scripts/` |
| **Unclear Tool Choice** | Does any step combine multiple operations in a fragile sequence naturally expressible as one function? | Script the procedure |
| **Rigid Contract** | Can you write `--help` text for this step right now without ambiguity? | CLI candidate |
| **Dual-Use Potential** | Would a user want to run this step from the terminal, outside the skill workflow? | Design as proper CLI from the start |
| **Consistency Critical** | Must this step produce bit-for-bit identical output for identical inputs? | Script — never LLM generation |

For each identified script candidate:
1. Choose the archetype from `{baseDir}/references/script-patterns.md` (init/validate/transform/package/query)
2. Scaffold the script in `scripts/` using the Python template from `{baseDir}/references/script-patterns.md`
3. Wire it into SKILL.md with: trigger condition, exact invocation using `exec` tool, output interpretation

**Wiring rule:** A script reference must state *when* to invoke (trigger condition), *how* to invoke (exact command with flags), and *what to do* with the result (exit code handling, which output fields matter).

Scripts are invoked via the `exec` tool (not `Bash`). Reference paths using `{baseDir}/scripts/script.py`.

### Step 5 — Check delegation

Read `{baseDir}/references/claw-patterns.md` for delegation patterns, `sessions_spawn` usage, cross-skill reference conventions, and tool group translations (Claude Code → OpenClaw tool name mapping).

Scan for existing resources before finalizing:

```
Review available OpenClaw skills (check ~/.openclaw/skills/ and workspace/skills/)
For each workflow step, ask: "Do we already have this?"
```

**Common delegation patterns:**
- To invoke another OpenClaw skill: tell the model to read `{baseDir}/../<other-skill>/SKILL.md` via the `read` tool, or instruct the user to type `/<other-skill-name>`
- For background delegation: use `sessions_spawn` (non-blocking; result announced back to chat)
- Documentation lookups: `exec: clawdocs get "<slug>" --no-header -q`

There is no `Skill` tool in OpenClaw — skills are invoked by the routing model, not programmatically from within another skill.

### Step 6 — Validate

When generating a new skill directory (not editing an existing single file):

```bash
python3 {baseDir}/scripts/validate_claw_skill.py <skill-directory> --output json
```

Exit 0 = proceed to Phase 3. Exit 1 = parse the `errors` array; each entry has `field`, `message`, `severity`. Resolve all `critical` and `major` items before writing to disk.

### Explain Your Choices

When presenting the generated skill/command to the user, briefly explain:
- **What you set and why** — "Added `metadata.openclaw.requires.bins: [jq]` because the skill calls jq in a subprocess"
- **What you excluded and why** — "Left `user-invocable` at default (true), `command-dispatch` omitted (skill routes through model)"
- **Add more trigger phrases if routing misses expected inputs**

## Phase 3: Deliver

### Output Paths

| Type | Location | When active |
|------|----------|-------------|
| Workspace skill | `<workspace>/skills/<name>/` | Next session in that workspace |
| Managed skill | `~/.openclaw/skills/<name>/` | Shared across all agents on this machine |

Skills are session-snapshotted — changes take effect on the next new session, not the current one.

### Write and Confirm

Before writing:
```
Writing to: [path]
This will [create new / overwrite existing] file.
Proceed?
```

### After Creation

Summarize what was created:
- Name and type
- Path and when it takes effect
- How to invoke/trigger
- Suggested test scenario

### Publish to ClawHub

Invoke only when the user explicitly requests distribution:

```bash
clawhub publish <skill-directory> --slug <slug> --version X.Y.Z --tags latest
```

Exit 0 = published. Exit 1 = validation or auth failure; read stdout for details.

## Phase 4: Evaluate

Score the generated skill/command:

| Dimension | Criteria |
|-----------|----------|
| **Clarity (0-10)** | Instructions unambiguous, objective clear |
| **Precision (0-10)** | Appropriate specificity without over-constraint |
| **Efficiency (0-10)** | Token economy — maximum value per token |
| **Completeness (0-10)** | Covers requirements without gaps or excess |
| **Usability (0-10)** | Practical, actionable, appropriate for target use |

**Target: 9.0/10.0.** If below, refine once addressing the weakest dimension, then deliver.

Re-run `validate_claw_skill.py` after any revisions and verify the validation checklist below before finalizing.

## Degrees of Freedom

| Level | When to Use | Format |
|-------|-------------|--------|
| **High freedom** | Multiple valid approaches, context-dependent decisions | Text instructions, heuristics |
| **Medium freedom** | Preferred pattern exists, some variation acceptable | Pseudocode, scripts with parameters |
| **Low freedom** | Fragile operations, consistency critical, specific sequence required | Exact scripts, few parameters |

## Quality Standards

**Format Economy:**
- Simple task → direct instruction, no sections
- Moderate task → light organization with headers
- Complex task → full semantic structure

**Remove ruthlessly:** Filler phrases, obvious implications, redundant framing, excessive politeness

## Validation Checklist

Before finalizing an OpenClaw skill or command:

**Structure:**
- [ ] SKILL.md exists with valid YAML frontmatter
- [ ] Frontmatter has `name` and `description` fields
- [ ] `metadata` field (if present) is single-line JSON on one line
- [ ] Markdown body is present and substantial
- [ ] Referenced files actually exist

**Description Quality:**
- [ ] Uses third person ("This skill should be used when...")
- [ ] Includes specific trigger phrases users would say (verbatim)
- [ ] Lists concrete scenarios ("create X", "configure Y")
- [ ] Not vague or generic

**OpenClaw Correctness:**
- [ ] No Claude Code-only fields: no `model`, `context`, `agent`, `allowed-tools`, `hooks`, `license`
- [ ] No Claude Code tool names referenced in body: no `Bash`, `WebSearch`, `WebFetch`, `Read`, `Write`, `Edit`, `Glob`, `Grep`, `Task`, `Skill`, `AskUserQuestion`, `EnterPlanMode`, `ExitPlanMode`
- [ ] Uses OpenClaw tool names: `exec`, `read`, `write`, `edit`, `web_search`, `web_fetch`, `sessions_spawn`
- [ ] Uses `{baseDir}` for skill-relative paths (not `$CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT`)
- [ ] Output path is OpenClaw workspace (`<workspace>/skills/`) or managed (`~/.openclaw/skills/`)

**Content Quality:**
- [ ] Body uses imperative/infinitive form, not second person
- [ ] Body is focused and lean (1,500–2,000 words ideal, <5k max)
- [ ] Detailed content moved to `references/`
- [ ] Scripts are executable and documented
- [ ] Script opportunities identified via five signal patterns
- [ ] Script references in SKILL.md include trigger condition, invocation (`exec`), output handling
- [ ] Consistency-critical steps are scripted, not left to LLM re-generation

**Progressive Disclosure:**
- [ ] Core concepts in SKILL.md
- [ ] Detailed docs in `references/`
- [ ] Utilities in `scripts/`
- [ ] SKILL.md references these resources
- [ ] `examples/` present if skill produces user-adaptable output (see `{baseDir}/examples/sample-command/SKILL.md` for a minimal command example)

## Error Handling

| Issue | Action |
|-------|--------|
| Unclear requirements | Ask clarifying questions before generating |
| Missing context | Request usage examples or target scenarios from user |
| Path issues | Verify target directory exists; let `init_claw_skill.py` create it |
| Type unclear | Default to skill (auto-triggered) if user hasn't specified |
| `clawdocs` unavailable | Proceed with current references — they are sufficient |

---

Execute phases sequentially. Always fetch current documentation first.