Phase 2.6 of the bio-manuscript pipeline: human review checkpoint. Use when presenting a refined proposal to a human reviewer, collecting explicit feedback, recording approval or requested changes, and routing the workflow back to the correct phase.
Installs into .claude/skills of the current project.
Are you the author of Bio Human Feedback?
Add the live security badge to your README. It updates with every re-scan.
[](https://www.skillsdirectory.com/skills/stanfish06-bio-human-feedback)
---
name: bio-human-feedback
description: "Phase 2.6 of the bio-manuscript pipeline: human review checkpoint. Use when presenting a refined proposal to a human reviewer, collecting explicit feedback, recording approval or requested changes, and routing the workflow back to the correct phase."
---
# bio-human-feedback
**Phase 2.6: Human review checkpoint (人类反馈验证)**
Present the refined proposal to a human reviewer, collect feedback, and decide whether to continue or loop back for revision.
## Purpose
1. Present the current proposal in a concise reviewable form
2. Wait for explicit human feedback
3. Record approval or requested changes
4. Route the workflow back to the correct phase if needed
## Inputs
- `FINAL_PROPOSAL.md`
- current round number
## Workflow
1. Present the proposal summary
2. Wait for approval or feedback
3. Classify the feedback severity
4. Record the response and decide the next phase
## Human Review Summary Format
```markdown
# Proposal Review - Round X
## Innovation Summary
- ...
## Figure Overview
- Figure 1:
- Figure 2:
## Experimental Plan
| Task | Dataset | Metric | Baseline |
|------|---------|--------|----------|
| ... | ... | ... | ... |
## Key Decisions Requiring Human Approval
1. ...
2. ...
## Reviewer Summary
| Reviewer | Score / status | Main advice |
|----------|----------------|-------------|
| Editor | ... | ... |
| Computational | ... | ... |
| Biological | ... | ... |
## Human Decision
- Approve and continue
- Request revisions
```
## Feedback Severity
- **Critical**: return to early planning
- **Major**: return to design / manuscript refinement
- **Minor**: revise locally and continue
## Files To Record
- `refine-logs/human-feedback/feedback-round-X.md`
- `refine-logs/HUMAN_APPROVAL.md`
## Usage
```bash
/bio-human-feedback --round 2 --proposal refine-logs/FINAL_PROPOSAL.md
```
## Notes
1. Do not continue automatically without explicit human approval.
2. Record all human feedback in the workspace.
3. Keep the requested decisions concise and actionable.
