Unanchored Dual-Persona Design & Motion Critique skill. Evaluates any UI surface cold from both a Design Director perspective (5-pillar 0-100 scorecard) and a Skeptical Target Visitor perspective, followed by a prioritized P0-P3 remediation plan.
Installs into .claude/skills of the current project.
Are you the author of Nongeneric Critique?
Add the live security badge to your README. It updates with every re-scan.
[](https://www.skillsdirectory.com/skills/kyaa-a-nongeneric-critique)
---
name: nongeneric-critique
description: >
Unanchored Dual-Persona Design & Motion Critique skill. Evaluates any UI surface cold from both a
Design Director perspective (5-pillar 0-100 scorecard) and a Skeptical Target Visitor perspective,
followed by a prioritized P0-P3 remediation plan.
---
# NonGeneric Dual-Persona Critique
When asked to critique, review, or audit a UI:
1. **Inspect the Surface Cold**:
Follow `../nongeneric/references/browser-verification.md` and inspect rendered evidence before reading the builder's rationale or static score. Mark unavailable evidence as not verified.
2. **Run the Deterministic Audit**:
```bash
node scripts/nongeneric.js audit <target>
```
This is a static-check score, not a visual or usability grade.
3. **Execute Unanchored Dual-Persona Evaluation**:
- **Persona 1 (Design & Motion Director)**: Use `../nongeneric/references/restrained-design.md`; do not penalize intentional stillness or one-family typography. Grade Typography (20), OKLCH Color & Atmosphere (20), Spatial Rhythm & 320px Responsive (20), Motion Appropriateness & Interaction Feedback (20), and Copy Authenticity & Task Fit (20).
- **Persona 2 (Skeptical Target Visitor)**: Evaluate according to Visitor Mode: offer and proof for persuade, task completion for operate, comprehension for read, participation and exit for experience. Execute the primary task and a relevant recovery path; report observed outcomes. This is expert review, not user research.
4. **Output Prioritized P0–P3 Remediation Plan**:
- Follow the impact-based severity rules in `../nongeneric/references/critique-and-finish.md`. Task blockers, lost work, and false completion take priority over visual polish; keep these review priorities separate from CLI rule severities.
- List exact file:line locations and concrete code replacements for every P0 and P1 issue.
- Separate static findings from rendered observations. Include viewport/state coverage and unverified dimensions. Do not assign a visual score without rendered evidence.
