Remove Ai Comments Chambersxdu

---
name: remove-ai-comments
description: Removes redundant, obvious, or "AI-flavored" comments from code to improve signal-to-noise ratio. Use when the user asks to "clean up comments", "remove AI comments", or makes a general request to refactor verbose code documentation.
---

# Remove "AI-Flavored" Comments

## Purpose
This skill guides the removal of low-value comments often generated by AI coding assistants. These comments typically narrate the code structure, state the obvious, or use verbose "tutorial style" explanations that clutter professional codebases.

## Identification Guide

Identify and remove comments that fall into these categories:

### 1. The "Narrator"
Comments that announce the start of a standard coding construct.
*   **Remove**: `// Begin function`
*   **Remove**: `// Loop through the array`
*   **Remove**: `// Define variables`
*   **Remove**: `// Initialize class`
*   **Remove**: `// End of if statement`

### 2. The "Translator"
Comments that merely translate the code line into English without adding context.
*   **Remove**: `i += 1 // Increment i`
*   **Remove**: `return result // Return the result`
*   **Remove**: `print(error) // Print the error`

### 3. The "Step-by-Step" (AI Tutorial Style)
Numbered steps that explain standard logic flows.
*   **Remove**: `// Step 1: Get the data`
*   **Remove**: `// Step 2: Validation`
*   **Remove**: `// Step 3: Return response`

### 4. The "Placeholder"
Empty or content-free comments left over from templates.
*   **Remove**: `// TODO: implementation` (only if the implementation is already there)
*   **Remove**: `/* Your code here */`

## Retention Rules (When NOT to remove)

Do **NOT** remove:
*   **Docstrings/JSDocs**: API documentation describing inputs, outputs, and public interfaces.
*   **"Why" Comments**: Explanations of *why* a decision was made (e.g., specific workarounds, optimizations, business logic reasoning).
*   **Warnings**: `WARNING`, `CAUTION`, or notes about side effects.
*   **Todos**: Actionable `TODO` or `FIXME` items (unless the user specifically asks to clear them).

## Workflow

1.  **Analyze**: Read the target file to understand its purpose.
2.  **Evaluate**: Look at the comments. Run `python scripts/comment_density.py <file>` (if available) to gauge initial density.
3.  **Process**:
    *   Iterate through comments.
    *   If a comment matches the "Identification Guide" for removal, delete it.
    *   If a comment explains complex logic, *keep it* or *refine it* if it's too verbose.
4.  **Cleanup**: Remove any resulting double empty lines or trailing whitespace.

## Example

**Before (AI Style):**

```python
# Import the datetime library
import datetime

# Function to get the current date
def get_date():
    # Step 1: Get today's date
    today = datetime.date.today()
    # Step 2: Return it
    return today
```

**After (Cleaned):**

```python
import datetime

def get_date():
    return datetime.date.today()
```