Pr

---
description: Create a GitHub pull request for a verified change. Reads verify-report.md, opens a PR with title from proposal and body from spec, enforces the configured test policy. Requires the gh CLI authenticated. Run after /specclaw:verify produces a verify-report.md. For Azure DevOps PRs, use /specclaw:pr-azdo instead.
---

# specclaw pr

## The staged-files gate (change 029)

Before staging anything, `specclaw-pr` runs:

```bash
specclaw-check-staged .specclaw <change>
```

It classifies every path the branch changes into four buckets:

| Bucket | Meaning | Default |
|---|---|---|
| `required-missing` | a mandatory artifact is not committed to the branch | **BLOCK** |
| `declared` | declared by a task, or inside the change dir | ok |
| `undeclared` | changed on the branch, declared by no task | WARN |
| `suspicious` | matches a junk pattern (`.session-id*`, `*.log`, `.env*`, …) | **BLOCK** |

**`undeclared` never blocks on its own.** `tasks.md` file lists are a scope *signal*, not a contract,
and a barrel export updated for a new module is a legitimate ripple that will never appear in one. A
gate that blocks a correct PR is worse than the silent failure it replaces.

**`workflow.staged_files_block` ships `false`**, so a BLOCK is reported and the PR still opens — the
same one-release rollout `code_review_block` took. Set it `true` once the buckets have earned it.

When there is something to judge — a non-empty `required-missing` or `suspicious`, or more than
`pr.audit_undeclared_threshold` undeclared paths — spawn the `staged-files-auditor` agent
(`workflow.staged_files_audit`). It writes `staged-files-report.md`, which this script links into the
PR body. Below that threshold the WARN stands on its own: a reviewer convened over two ripples is a
bill with no finding attached.

Two escape hatches, and they are not interchangeable:

- `pr.allowed_extra_paths` — a file that genuinely belongs but is never declared (a CHANGELOG). Wins
  over every other rule.
- `.gitignore` — where a recurring junk pattern actually belongs. The report says so by name.

**Always create the PR through this script.** A hand-rolled `gh pr create` bypasses all of the above,
which is how PRs shipped without their proposal three times on one change.

**First, run** `specclaw-ensure-init .specclaw` — idempotently creates `.specclaw/` if it doesn't exist (silent if already initialized; auto-inits using the current directory's basename as the project name).

Create a GitHub PR for a verified change. Requires `verify-report.md` (build + verify must complete first).

1. **Code review block (conditional):** Read `workflow.code_review_block` from `.specclaw/config.yaml`. If `true`:
   - Check if `.specclaw/changes/<change>/review-report.md` exists. If it does not exist, warn: "code_review_block is enabled but no review-report.md found — run /specclaw:verify first" and continue.
   - If `review-report.md` exists and verdict is `CHANGES_REQUESTED`, **abort** with: "PR blocked: code review verdict is CHANGES_REQUESTED. Fix BLOCK findings in review-report.md then re-run /specclaw:verify." List all BLOCK findings from the report before aborting.
2. **Validate:** `specclaw-validate-change .specclaw <change> pr`. Exits with a warning (exit 0) if a PR already exists for this change. Fails if `verify-report.md` is missing.
2. **Run:** `specclaw-pr .specclaw <change>` — **always** create the PR through this script, never hand-roll `gh pr create`. `specclaw-pr` stages and commits the full `.specclaw/changes/<change>/` planning trail (proposal, spec, design, tasks, status, verify-report) into the branch and **aborts if any of it is left uncommitted** — a raw `gh pr create` skips this and ships a PR missing the proposal artifacts.
   - **First run:** prompts for test policy (`none|unit|e2e|both`), saves it to `config.yaml` under `pr.test_policy`. Never prompts again.
   - **Test enforcement:** if policy is not `none`, verifies `build.test_command` is set and that `verify-report.md` contains test evidence. Fails (strict) or warns (non-strict) if evidence is missing.
   - **Version bump:** if `plugin.version_files` is set in `config.yaml`, compares each file's `"version"` against the base branch. If unchanged, auto-bumps the patch version and commits before PR creation. Configure in `.specclaw/config.yaml`:
     ```yaml
     plugin:
       version_files:
         - "plugins/specclaw/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
         - ".claude-plugin/marketplace.json"
     ```
   - **PR creation:** builds title from `proposal.md`, body from `spec.md` + `verify-report.md`, runs `gh pr create --base main`.
   - **GitHub sync:** if `github.sync: true`, includes `Closes #N` in the PR body.
   - **Saves URL:** appends `**PR:** <url>` to `status.md`.
3. **Update project context:** After the PR URL is saved, rewrite `.specclaw/context.md` to incorporate decisions from this change:
   - Run `specclaw-update-context .specclaw <change>` — this outputs an LLM prompt.
   - Feed the prompt to a coding agent that rewrites `context.md` in place (architecture-doc style: replaces stale info, merges new decisions).
   - If `context.md` changed, commit it: `git add .specclaw/context.md && git commit -m "docs(context): update project context after <change>"` and push.
   - Errors here are non-blocking — warn and continue.
4. Report the PR URL to the user.

**CI outer loop (if `loop.ci_gate: true`):** once the PR branch is pushed, the CI tier of `/specclaw:loop` (Step 3 / `specclaw-loop ci-poll`) polls GitHub Actions checks and iterates fixes until they are green, or `loop.ci_max_iterations` / `loop.ci_timeout_seconds` halts and escalates. This is a cross-reference only — PR creation above is unchanged, and nothing extra runs when `loop.ci_gate` is false.