Mk 448

---
name: mk-448
description: "Consulting Response Evidence Check. Use when work requires checks of whether claims cite data actually obtained; process the specified inputs using this method and verify the deliverable"
---

# MK-448 | Consulting Response Evidence Check

For ordinary chat, upload `packs/mk-448.md`, which includes the shared rules, this method, and required references

## Purpose

This skill delivers: **Checks of whether claims cite data actually obtained**

Maintain, observe, and gather evidence first are valid decisions; do not conceal a lack of evidence behind a well-organized report

## Required inputs

Provide: Complete consultant answer, citations or readable sources, original question and verifiable business data

## Method steps

1. Each consulting output lists preliminary judgment, supporting data, main problems, corresponding course logic, priority recommendations, and additional data needed next
2. Recommendations must identify the page and module to improve and explain their priority
3. Label insufficient data as such; do not fill the gap with abstract SEO advice or model guesses

## Calculation and interpretation

This task only inventories work; old specifications are not new authorization, and tools must actually be available before claiming execution

## Required output fields

| Order | Field | How to complete |
|---:|---|---|
| 1 | Consultant statement and location | Use the supplied source, calculation, or explicit unknown |
| 2 | Claim type | Use the supplied source, calculation, or explicit unknown |
| 3 | Cited source and location | Use the supplied source, calculation, or explicit unknown |
| 4 | What the source actually supports | Use the supplied source, calculation, or explicit unknown |
| 5 | Supported, partial, contradicted or unverifiable | Use the supplied source, calculation, or explicit unknown |
| 6 | Corrected wording and reason | Use the supplied source, calculation, or explicit unknown |
| 7 | Missing source | Use the supplied source, calculation, or explicit unknown |

## Verification cases

**MK-448-A1 | Source supports only part of a compound claim**

Expected: Split claims, mark partial support and revise unsupported wording

## Method sources

Original file: SEO 108｜AI 搜尋顧問 GPT｜Prompt 完整版講義

Source locator: consulting

Source basis: extracted from course materials

Original URL: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1UQVafPo3xVxC2PQ_muPU1qDKUo1M-WXH6A7dEVV5lJY/edit

English translation of source excerpt retained in the master sheet:

> You are an SEO / AEO / GEO performance diagnostic consultant specializing in helping brands review website content, AI citability, external brand context, and the search-to-sale path